Showing posts with label Chesapeake Planning Commission. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chesapeake Planning Commission. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 16, 2012

A Planning Commissioner Speaks Up for Chesapeake Hens

A supporter of 4 Chesapeake Hens, Tom Powell, had written a letter regarding the treatment our group received at the Planning Commission's public hearing on October 10. We published Tom's letter in an earlier post.

Commissioner Adam Perry, one of three who had voted in favor of hens, emailed Tom this well-worded reply on October 15:

Hello Mr. Powell,

I appreciate your thorough and thoughtful e-mail.  You have made some very good points and put our actions into perspective.

I voted for TA-Z12-07, and amended the proposal to allow for up to six chickens and to remove the burdensome 6 ft. fencing requirement.  I voted this way and proposed the amendments because during my thorough investigation into the issue, including backyard site visits, interviews and research, I found that other than psychological anguish due to unfounded stereotypes (not facts),  I could not find any substantive reasons that hens would actually bother anyone.

I can’t speak for other Commissioners.  I do not know why they chose not to ask questions or explain themselves, particularly since there was no opposition at the meeting.

Personally, my questions were answered.  I agree that you should have the right to have chickens on your property so long as they are properly cared for and do not interfere with your neighbor’s right to pursue their own lives.

I try very hard to be consistent with my votes.  Personal freedom and property rights are very important to me.

 Please contact me if you have any further questions.

Adam Perry
Chesapeake Planning Commission

Update: On November 20, Chesapeake City Council voted 6-3 to allow hens with certain restriction in residential areas.

Monday, October 15, 2012

Hens Back at City Council

"4 Chesapeake Hens" has had a setback at the Planning Commission. The Commission voted to deny our request for changes in the zoning laws to allow backyard laying hens in residential areas in Chesapeake, VA.

But we have not given up our quest. We are organizing our response. We are on the City Council's agenda for November 20.

In the meantime, if you wish to help us plan and organize, join our Facebook page. We post frequent updates and opportunities to help. The link is at the top of this post. If you are a Chesapeake resident who cares about this issue, contact City Council. Council has the final decision, so the time for public input is between now and November 20, 2012.

Update: On November 20, Chesapeake City Council voted 6-3 to allow hens with certain restriction in residential areas. 

Thursday, October 11, 2012

The Planning Commission's Rationale? -- We May Never Know!

Was the Planning Commission's recent recommendation to continue to restrict laying hens in Chesapeake, VA, a rational, thoughtful one? One based on data and research? Or one based on ignorance and some arcane process of decision-making prior to hearing out all the facts of the case?

What makes the Commissioners' vote most disturbing to us is that we residents, local business-owners, and other members of the pubic have no way of knowing. There was no public discussion and no rationale for any of the nay-sayers' votes. Therefore their negative vote was surprising in light of the fact that nine residents spoke for changes in the local laws concerning laying hens, and nobody spoke against: not one resident, not one Commissioner. Our members sat through the evening, waiting to be asked questions. There were none. The one Commissioner who spoke on the topic only had positive things to say about our proposal to allow up to six laying hens on all single-family residential lots.

Here is what one of our speakers, Tom Powell, had to say to Commissioners in the following articulate email. He granted us permission to reproduce it here:

Commissioners,
I have lived on the Southside since 1990 (Norfolk, Virginia Beach, and
now Chesapeake since 2008).

I was present at the meeting last night and was very delighted to see
how you performed your duties with regard to the following:

UP-08-06 Blake's Auto service.
- I drive by his business every day to and from work. He has
continually been improving his business appearance since I moved to
Chesapeake. On a long strip of Military Hwy where most of the
businesses do not have much curb appeal his does.
- You overturned the staff recommendation with detailed discussion.
There was no public opposition. You recognized the only opposition to
Mr. Blake was the changing city ordinances and his being a small
business owner with few resources. WELL DONE! I will start to visit
Blake's Auto Service in the near future.

UP-12-23 Caren's Caring Place.
- You overturned the staff recommendation with detailed discussion.
One of you even said how his extended family has utilized similar
services as he was growing up. There was no public opposition. You
recognized the only opposition to Mrs. Ferebee was the changing State
and City ordinances. Being a small business owner with no complaints
in the last 15 years of her business, you granted her a use permit.
WELL DONE! I wish her God's speed.

UP-12-29 Xtreme Window Tint and Detailing
- You overturned the staff recommendation with detailed discussion.
One of you even called out the numerous improvements made by the
owner. The owner had a very detailed plan of how to be a good neighbor
with many stipulations. You saw the wisdom that many of these
stipulations were hard to enforce and were already spoken to in the
numerous other ordinances. You granted his use permit and reduced the
stipulations to only a reasonable few. WELL DONE!

UP-12-25 Executive Tattoo
- You upheld the staff recommendation with detailed discussion and
numerous questions to the sole public opposition presented. You
discerned the difference between actual day care facilities and
businesses. You exposed the accusation of a tattoo parlor being
equivalent to a penitentiary or like facility. Of my wife's three
tattoos, she is a law abiding citizen and does not encourage our son
to lead a life of crime by having them or visiting a tattoo parlor.
WELL DONE!

Up to this point, most if not all your votes were unanimous and made
sense. However with regards to the following:

TA-Z-12-07 Amending Chesapeake Code for allowing hens in residential districts.
- You upheld the staff recommendation. NO discussion, one comment from
a commissioner. NO questions. NO public opposition. The silence was
deafening.
- Six Chesapeake taxpayers and one Norfolk resident presented facts
and evidence of how backyard flocks are helping cities across the
nation. One presenter gave you a flyer from the early 1900s "Uncle Sam
Expects You To Keep Hens and Raise Chickens."  This flyer may be
dated, but as one of the Commissioners positively spoke to his
upbringing with neighborhood daycare facilities (which is frowned on
by "modern" zoning); this is something valuable from our past we need
to get back to.
-A motion was quickly made to change the code to allow 6 hens and
remove the six foot privacy fence requirement. This was quickly
seconded and then put to a vote. 3 for and 4 against. Commission chair
was reminded something needed to be voted on and forwarded to the City
Council. He asked for a motion. With delay one of you moved to accept
the staff recommendation and deny a change to the city code. With
greater delay, chair repeatedly asked for a second to the motion. The
vote was the same.

Therefore, I am completely puzzled. You did not engage any of the
speakers. No one spoke negatively. No one mentioned any public outcry
against backyard flocks. No one presented a single fact to the
negative. Your silence on TA-Z12-07 gave the impression of being
prejudice, narrow-minded and aloof. You did not give that impression
for any of the other issues before you last night. I thought a public
hearing was just that, public. It "appeared" your decisions were made
in private and before the presentations were made. As a current
Chesapeake taxpayer, I want to know what our publicly elected and
appointed officials are doing with funds I have entrusted to them.

What if you voted down Mrs. Ferebee or Mr. Blake with no explanation
to your decision? That type of a decision would be perceived
outrageous from public officials (and rightly so). Please do not make
future decisions without presenting facts or at least an opinion or
uninformed conjecture. This is what makes the public very suspicious
of elected/appointed officials.

Very respectfully,
Mr. T. H. Powell

Update: On November 20, Chesapeake City Council voted 6-3 to allow hens with certain restriction in residential areas.

4 Chesapeake Hens at the Planning Commission

Last night was a roller-coaster ride for 4 Chesapeake Hens, the grass-roots community group that is trying to get backyard laying hens legalized in Chesapeake, VA. Our group's ideals and rationale are laid out in a well-researched document, "A Case for Chesapeake Hens." (This document is now available in a revised edition). The current ordinance is that all chickens are livestock and allowed only on land zoned agricultural, with one exception: RE-1 "residential estates" of three acres or more are allowed four hens, no roosters, on the property. Then, and only then, are hens pets.  Here's a recap of what has happened in recent months:

  1. After public appearances on separate occasions by our members, City Council voted to send the "hen issue" to the Planning Commission for a review and a recommendation. 
  2. The Planning Department drafted an ordinance that it publicized would allow hens in the City. Once we actually had the chance to read the ordinance, however, our group came to the conclusion that it was "passively-aggressively" against chickens. If passed, it would have allowed four hens, no roosters, on all single-family residential lots. But it would have made changes that classified *all* hens as livestock, even the ones that under current ordinance are considered pets. Owners would only be allowed to keep four hens, not the six our group has been requesting so that residents could legally purchase chicks. Worst of all, the ordinance would have required owners of these hens, who are already required to keep them in a sturdy pen in the backyard, to privacy-fence their entire back lot in order to keep the hens, an unnecessary and prohibitive expense. 
  3. The Planning Department came out with a recommendation to the Planning Commission to deny even this restrictive ordinance. It used as its justification the City's Staff Report,  a compilation of reports from various City departments that would potentially be affected by the ordinance. Most of the departments were against chickens in the City, but for reasons that we could--and mostly did-- refute. Many statements in the reports were based on fear and conjecture rather than data. Animal Control stated that stray birds could be difficult to round up, for example. This statement totally ignores the fact that chickens are totally night-blind and can easily be rounded up and handled after dark. There was no hard data from other municipalities to support the supposition that stray hens are a concern anywhere else in the country where micro-flocks are allowed. The Health Department's well-researched recommendations seemed most amenable to the idea of pet hens. It contradicted Animal Control's and other departments' concerns about the spread of disease by the hens, for example. Its report acknowledges that hens, like other pets, can potentially spread certain diseases to humans. But it states that "such diseases are uncommon enough that they should not discourage bird-keeping." The Health Department also recommends common-sense precautions, such as supervising children and hand-washing, to minimize the risk of  salmonella transmission. 
  4. We invited an author, scientist, and hen expert, Patricia Foreman, to speak at the Chesapeake Central Library on Tuesday, October 9. Her talk was inspiring and informative. We had invited all the City Council and Planning Commission members to attend. The spouse of one City Council member came, but no officials.
  5. Last night, October 10, was the Planning Commission meeting itself. About twenty supporters, all dressed in red shirts, attended the meeting. Nine of us spoke. All speakers were in favor of the draft law with changes to allow for six hens and the removal of the privacy fence requirement. There were no speakers opposed. A brief account of the meeting by a reporter, Marjon Rostami, is available here, and the entire Planning Commission Meeting was videotaped and can be watched at this link. Our group appears at about 1:35.
  6. After our well-researched, well-documented, and heartfelt presentations, three of the seven Planning Commissioners present at the meeting, namely Adam Perry, Greg Bell and William Small, proposed and voted for an ordinance we could live with: to allow up to six backyard hens on single-family residential lots, to be kept in pens, with no fencing requirement for the lot. Nobody spoke against the proposal: not anyone from the community, not anyone from the Commission, nobody. There was no debate. Nobody asked any of us any questions. The one Commissioner who spoke on the matter, Bell, was positive. He said he'd done his own research on the facts our group had presented in "A Case for Chesapeake Hens," and he could find no documentation to refute any of the facts we'd presented. So for a few heart-stopping seconds, we thought we might get a positive recommendation. 
  7.  Unfortunately, four Councilors voted against the motion for reasons that may never be publicly explained. These same four Councilors voted to deny even the restrictive proposal with the privacy fence, so this will be  the official recommendation from the Commission when the matter goes back to Council.
As far as how members of our group feel about secretive way the Commissioners went about their decision-making and voting on this matter, and what our plans are from here, that's fodder for other posts!

**Update on 10/18/12: Lanetter Lepper recently published the research she presented to the Planning Commission. Her report details the minimal impact of permitting chickens in other cities. Her document may be read on Google Docs.

**Update on 11/15/12: Chicken Activist Saad Ringa has started a YouTube Channel with videos of our activist efforts. Watch the Planning Commission speeches and then the Commissioners' vote. If you're a Chesapeake resident, you'll be ashamed of how the Commissioners acted. And you can't see on camera the Commissioner who actually walked out of the meeting when most of our speakers were presenting, and then walked in to vote against the hens, with no explanation! He could have at least had the courtesy to listen.

Update: On November 20, Chesapeake City Council voted 6-3 to allow hens with certain restriction in residential areas.

Wednesday, October 3, 2012

Time to Fight for the Right to Have Hens!

Patricia Foreman, the author of  City Chicks, wrote some rousing words about an upcoming public hearing in Lexington. It is so appropriate to our situation here in Chesapeake that she gave me permission to tweak it and re-post it here.

Chesapeake Chickens - Public Hearing Announcement

ALERT!! Chicken Public Hearing, Wednesday, Oct. 10, 7 pm City Hall

Please WEAR SOMETHING RED to the hearing to show you are a local foods supporter.

The proposed code is at this link. 
It has restrictions that passively-agressively prevent most families from keeping chickens. 

This public hearing is not just about chickens—it's about so much more that affects us all—and our lifestyles.
• It's about having access to local, HEALTHY foods. 
• It's about employing chickens' skill sets in gardening, (as herbiciders, pesticiders and fertilizer creators).
• It about reducing carbon footprints with food that doesn't have to travel 1,200 miles through feedlots and factory farms. 
• It's about biomass recycling of food and yard "waste" and creating topsoil.
• It's about reducing the solid waste management stream that saves taxpayer dollars.
• It's about living green and walking your talk.
• It's about humane treatment of animals.
• It's about teaching kids where food comes from, including gardening.
• It's about the right to grow food on land you own.
• It's about emergency preparedness.
• It's even about national security. The Department of Defense has repeatedly stated that our weakest links in National Security is America's food and water supply. 

Keeping a family flocks, and supporting local agriculture are the most important things communities can do to help navigate these challenging times. For more information on why, and details about the Chicken Training Series, see www.ChickensAndYOU.com. Or hear Pat Foreman herself give an evening talk on Tuesday, October 9, at 5 PM at the Chesapeake Central Library. Tickets must be purchased here in advance-- proceeds benefit the Gossamer Foundation.

Even if you don't want chickens, please support those who do. 

Pass this message along to others who might be able to come and show City Council that the chicken movement—and locavore foods is happening all across America. This is a serious matter, and not just a personal frivolity of a few. 

Update: On November 20, Chesapeake City Council voted 6-3 to allow hens with certain restriction in residential areas.

Monday, October 1, 2012

Chesapeake Planning Commission Update

I called the Planning Department today on behalf of 4 Chesapeake Hens to learn more about how the local political process works. Our group is trying to change the laws in Chesapeake, VA, so more residents can legally own laying hens.

My contact was very polite and informative. Here is what I learned:

1. If our group wants to have input of any kind into the laws regarding laying hens in Chesapeake, there are really only two places to do so: at the Planning Commission meetings when public input is requested, and at the City Council meetings themselves.

2. Staff Recommendations will be published online this Friday, October 5. This report will publish the input that the Health Department, Animal Control, and other City agencies have about the issue of chickens in Chesapeake. This report will be important for us to study.

3. There can be a variety of outcomes to the Commission meeting, and there's really no predicting how it will turn out until it happens:

A. The Commission could recommend that the law be changed to what the Planning Department has recently recommended, even though our group has objections to some of its provisions, as outlined in earlier posts.

B. The Commission could disagree with the Planning Department and recommend to the City Council that the current law be left as it is. Our group contends this law is unfair because only those with the money and inclination to own "residential estates" of three acres or more (RE-1) are permitted to own hens as pets.

C. The Commission could amend the Planning Department's proposed changes and send on the amended proposal to the City Council.

D. The Commission could decide to continue the matter and to send the "hen issue" back to the Planning Department for further study.

4. Whatever the Commission's recommendations, our group will still have an opportunity to address our side of the "hen issue" when it comes back before City Council.

In other words, it is critically important that "4 Chesapeake Hens" put pressure on the Planning Commission at the meeting on Wednesday, October 10. Those of us who plan to speak will work together and develop our strategy this week. We ask that everyone else who wants laying hens for as wide a range of Chesapeake residents as possible, everyone who thinks the current laws are unfair, and everyone who thinks that it is ridiculous to require a six foot privacy fence to contain hens that are already kept in a pen on one's own property, to come to the meeting at 6:30 PM dressed in red. Those of us who plan to do the talking need a strong, visible show of support from the community to help us get our points across.

If you care, be there!

**Update on 10/15/12: Last Wednesday we appeared before the Commission. We nearly got a recommendation we could live with, but it lost by one vote. The Commission voted to deny our request for changes in the zoning laws regarding chickens. The matter now goes back to City Council, which actually makes the decision. That hearing is set for November 20.

Update: On November 20, Chesapeake City Council voted 6-3 to allow hens with certain restriction in residential areas.

Saturday, September 29, 2012

Hampton Roads Sustainability Expo!

4 Chesapeake Hens spent the day at the Hampton Roads Sustainability Expo in Virginia Beach. Tom Powell and his family were there, as was my friend and fellow Chicken-Activist, Wendy Camacho. The Expo even allowed us to bring a couple of hens as poster-girls for the movement. Here we are, with our poster-chickens:

L-R: Wendy, 2 Gold Sex-Link Hens, Mary Lou and Tom

I was pleased to have a chance to meet our local online food co-op and several of its vendors at the event. The Virginia Urban Homesteaders League was there, beekeepers and beekeeping groups, local food activists, and so many others! Many of them are rooting for us to win the right to keep our backyard hens, and we thanked them all for their support, interest, and appreciation today. We are not alone!

Tom's son, Xavier, poses with us, too!

Wendy and I presented "A Case for Chesapeake Hens: Chickens on the Road to Sustainability," which was well received. 

Photo courtesy of Lanette Grovesteen Lepper

 Many people stopped at our booth. Tom, Wendy, and I all talked until we were hoarse. It was a pleasant surprise to see how many people already knew us, knew our group, liked our page, read this blog, and were willing and able to help us in some way. It was a great feeling. Several people told us they loved the hens--who stole the show!-- and that our booth was their favorite at the whole event.

We gave out lots of flyers advertising Pat Foreman's upcoming appearance at the Chesapeake Central Library on Tuesday, October 9. We encouraged residents from Norfolk, Portsmouth, and Virginia Beach to check out http://www.backyardchickens.com/ as well as our own Facebook page to network with others to change the laws in their own communities. We urged Chesapeake residents to dress in red and come to the Planning Commission meeting on October 10 at 7 PM, where we plan to object to recent recommendations regarding changes to the zoning laws by the Planning Department. Supporters will arrive dressed in red, the color of the "Little Red Hen."

Why do we object? One provision would limit hens to four per household, despite the fact that both local and state laws make it a misdemeanor to sell chicks (under 8 weeks of age) in flocks of less than six. We do not mind the proposal that the hens be kept in pens but find the requirement of an additional six-foot privacy fence around the entire back yard to be unnecessary and burdensome. Everyone who heard about requiring a fence in addition to a secure pen thought it was ridiculous, and many people promised to come out in force as a show of support.

We hope they follow through. We suspect they will.

How will the Planning Commission React? Stay tuned to find out. Or, better yet, come to the Commission meeting, dressed in red, and be among the first to know.

Update: On November 20, Chesapeake City Council voted 6-3 to allow hens with certain restriction in residential areas.

Thursday, September 27, 2012

Why Does 4 Chesapeake Hens Want Six Chicks?

Regular readers know that I belong to a group, 4 Chesapeake Hens, that advocates changes to the zoning laws in Chesapeake, VA. Current law allows chickens only on land zoned agricultural. There is one exception: owners of "residential estates" of 3 acres or more my have four hens kept in a pen.

Potential changes are before the Planning Commission right now. Unfortunately, the proposed changes are still unnecessarily restrictive and expensive. The Planning Department has proposed that hens be allowed upon all single-family residential lots, but only four hens, which must be kept confined to a pen, with easements for the coop, and with a six foot privacy fence around the back yard, to boot!

We are most upset about the privacy fence, but fellow chicken activist and political guru, Andrea Margrave, recently published this detailed account of why the four-hen limit is also a terrible expense. The laws Andrea refers to (about buying chicks in flocks of six) are at the municipal level in Chesapeake but are also reflective of Virginia state code:

Sigh. Just did the numbers on ordering juvenile birds as opposed to chicks. (from McMurray hatchery) Just 4 laying hens of a common breed (Rhode Island Reds) are 17.95 EACH, for a total of 71.80 for 4 hens. Then, add shipping of.... areyousittingdown.... $111.00, for a grand total of 182.80.

THIS is why we need the Planning Commission to change the number of hens from 4 to 6, so people can buy locally and LEGALLY from farm stores or order chicks from a hatchery in amounts larger than 4.

It is confusing, but the law states that you aren't allowed to buy or sell less than 6 chicks at a time, up to the age of 2 months. After 2 months you can buy any number the retailers will allow. Unfortunately, hatcheries don't sell 'juvenile birds' until they are at least 15 weeks old (old enough to be 'hardened off' from the cold, and just on the verge of starting to lay eggs).

I checked on a few others that weren't sold out, and Meyers was 136.80 for 4 juveniles including shipping. Cackle didn't even list juvies, only a few select grown birds, mostly rare birds like a single Lakenvelder for $75 (the cheapest!) or one Silkie for $125 shipped.

Compare the price of chicks, freshly hatched, or even fertilized eggs to incubate yourself. 6 RIR female chicks only cost 15.78, and the shipping is less than that at 14.70. 6-10 hatching eggs will run you anywhere from $30 to $45 shipped from McMurray, even less other places. Meyer will ship for free any number of eggs from a huge variety of breeds, with the exception of a 'small order' surcharge if you get 6 or less. So if you get RIR's they are $3.87 per egg plus the $7 surcharge. 6 chicks would set you back even less, but I couldn't see if shipping was included for the chicks or not.

My point is, it is REALLY OUTRAGEOUS the cost to ship mature birds compared to getting just 6 chicks locally (Southern States was GIVING them away with the purchase of a bag of feed this spring!). Neither SS nor St. Brides will sell you less than 6, because I asked. And with the new Tractor Supply opening up sometime in the coming year, we will have plenty of options to buy locally, if the City will allow it.... 
 **Update: On November 20, Chesapeake City Council voted 6-3 to allow hens with certain restriction in residential areas.
 

Monday, September 17, 2012

Updated News From the Chesapeake Planning Commission

I received an email today from Beverly R. Hanson, the Office Coordinator for the City of Chesapeake's Planning Department. This was in response to " A Case for Chesapeake Hens," which I had submitted on behalf of 4 Chesapeake Hens for the Planning Commission's review.
  
She thanked me for providing the document and promised to forward it to the Planning Commission in anticipation of its meeting on October 10, 2012. She also said a proposed ordinance will be available online at www.cityofchesapeake.net/planning within the next few days, and the staff recommendation will be available on or after October 5th.

This is exciting news! Will the proposed ordinance be something our group can support? Will the staff recommendation side with the chickens? Stay tuned: we will find out in the days and weeks to come!

Update: I just found out that the Planning Commission meeting on October 10 is open to the public. So that will be a busy week 4 Chesapeake Hens. We will be going to Pat Foreman's book-signing and lecture at the Central Library on the 9th, and then to the Planning Commission meeting on the 10th. But the end is near, and we are hopeful that it will bode well for the chickens.

Update: The Planning Commission has published its proposed hen ordinance here.  4 Chesapeake Hens is gathering comments from our Facebook page and from a related group, "Backyard Chickens for Chesapeake." Public comments are allowed at Planning Commission meetings, so we plan to make our opinions known at the October 10 hearing. We will be at that meeting dressed in red. Those who wish to speak need to sign up before 7 PM. Previous meetings can be watched online to get an idea of how the meetings are run. The meetings can also be watched live online at home by those unable to attend.

 Update: On November 20, Chesapeake City Council voted 6-3 to allow hens with certain restriction in residential areas.